GENUINE NEW YORK PIZZA

Made Right Here on the Treasure Coast!

PROUDLY SERVING MULTIPLE LOCATIONS!

Discover Benny's

REAL NEW YORK PIZZA!

Welcome to Downtown Benny’s Pizza, your neighborhood Pizzeria, where we have the best NY Style Pizza. We use only the freshest ingredients to create our authentic Italian dishes. We hear it time and time again, Downtown Benny’s has the best NY style pizza in Florida. Even New Yorkers tell us they can’t get pizza like Downtown Benny’s back home. To achieve such terrific results, we start with a 70 year old family dough recipe and only the freshest ingredients. Then we bring it all together in our brick oven pizza, making sure it comes out thin and crispy.

In addition to the great pizza, we offer other delicious menu items from chicken wings, to philly cheesesteaks, salads, gyros, pasta & more!

WEEKLY SPECIALS

MONDAY & TUESDAY SPECIAL

Extra Large Cheese Pizza ALL DAY!

$13.95
2 SLICES OF CHEESE PIZZA & CAN OF SODA
$6.95
EXTRA LARGE 1 TOPPING PIZZA, 10 WINGS & 2 LITER SODA

$35.95
2 LARGE 1-TOPPING PIZZAS & 2 LITER SODA

$35.95

CLICK TO CALL THE FOLLOWING LOCATIONS:

ORDER ON SLICE FROM THE FOLLOWING LOCATIONS:

Benny's Downtown Pizza - Stuart and Port St Lucie Pizza

New York Pizza

Served with your favorite toppings and made the way it's supposed to be!

Button
Benny's Downtown Pizza - Stuart and Port St Lucie Pizza

Meals & Entrees

Home cooked meals to start and end your day right every time!

Button
Benny's Downtown Pizza - Stuart and Port St Lucie Pizza

Italian Desserts

Real Italian desserts that will keep you coming back for more!

Button
Benny's Downtown Pizza - Stuart and Port St Lucie Pizza

We've Got It All!

Our diverse menu has a little something for everyone to enjoy!

Button
meatArtboard 5

Only the freshest ingredients available are good enough us! 

All of our toppings are fresh and never frozen...always delicious! 

Our meats & cheeses are from only the best suppliers around!

Our desserts are like nothing else you'll find outside of Italy!

meatArtboard 5

Only the freshest ingredients available are good enough us! 

All of our toppings are fresh and never frozen...always delicious! 

Our meats & cheeses are from only the best suppliers around!

Our desserts are like nothing else you'll find outside of Italy!

All of Our Meals Are

Always Fresh...Always Delicious

We use fresh wholesome ingredients in every dish. From our fresh meat to organic veggies, we ensure that each bite is as healthy and flavorful as humanly possibly. 

Contact Us Any Time

Contact Us Form

(Next to Jensen Bowl)

OPEN SUN-THUR FROM 11AM-9PM AND

FRIDAY & SATURDAY FROM 11AM-10PM

(Next to CarMax)

OPEN SUN-THUR FROM 11AM-9PM AND

FRIDAY & SATURDAY FROM 11AM-10PM

(Next to CarMax)

(Next to CarMax)

OPEN SUN-THUR FROM 11AM-9PM AND

FRIDAY & SATURDAY FROM 11AM-10PM

(Next to CarMax)

(Across from Floresta Elementary)

OPEN SUN-THUR FROM 11AM-9PM AND

FRIDAY & SATURDAY FROM 11AM-10PM

(Next to WeBuyAnyCar)

OPEN SUN-THUR FROM 11AM-9PM AND

FRIDAY & SATURDAY FROM 11AM-10PM

(Next to WeBuyAnyCar)

(Across from Nelson's Produce)

OPEN SUN-THUR FROM 11AM-9PM AND

FRIDAY & SATURDAY FROM 11AM-10PM

(Near the Ft Pierce Inlet Marina)

OPEN SUN-THUR FROM 11AM-9PM AND

FRIDAY & SATURDAY FROM 11AM-10PM

(Next to WeBuyAnyCar)

(Formerly Rusano's Pizza)

OPEN SUN-THUR FROM 11AM-9PM AND

FRIDAY & SATURDAY FROM 11AM-10PM

(Next to WeBuyAnyCar)

OPEN SUN-THUR FROM 11AM-9PM AND

FRIDAY & SATURDAY FROM 11AM-10PM

(Next to WeBuyAnyCar)

(Across from Nelson's Produce)

(Next to WeBuyAnyCar)

OPEN SUN-THUR FROM 11AM-9PM AND

FRIDAY & SATURDAY FROM 11AM-10PM

(Near Ft Pierce Marina)

Share by: